How did the Wayfair decision change sales tax requirements?
Before 2018, you only had to collect sales tax in states where your business had a physical presence. A warehouse, office, employee, or even inventory stored in a fulfillment center could create that obligation. But selling to customers across state lines from your home office or through a website? No requirement to collect their state’s sales tax.
The Supreme Court’s ruling in South Dakota v. Wayfair changed everything. The court decided that economic activity alone could create a sales tax collection obligation, even without any physical connection to a state. This concept is called economic nexus.
Now most states require you to collect and remit sales tax once you exceed certain thresholds within their borders. The common threshold is $100,000 in sales or 200 transactions within a calendar year, though some states have dropped the transaction count and only use the sales amount. Each state sets its own rules and can change them at any time.
For online sellers, this created a significant compliance burden. A business selling nationwide might trigger nexus in dozens of states. Each state has different tax rates, different rules about which products are taxable, different filing frequencies, and different registration requirements. You can’t just collect one rate and send it somewhere.
The practical impact depends on your business model. If you only sell locally within Massachusetts and the Merrimack Valley, the Wayfair decision might not affect you directly. If you sell through Shopify, Amazon, or your own website to customers across multiple states, you’re likely dealing with economic nexus in several jurisdictions right now.
Tracking where you’ve crossed thresholds requires ongoing monitoring. You need to know your sales by state, register with tax authorities when you hit thresholds, configure correct rates in your sales platform, file returns on each state’s schedule, and keep up with rule changes. A small business bookkeeping service can help track your state-by-state sales and flag when you’re approaching nexus triggers.
Software like TaxJar or Avalara can automate calculations and filing, but only if someone configures it correctly and monitors threshold crossings. The software doesn’t handle registration or catch errors without proper oversight.
If you’re already selling in multiple states and haven’t addressed sales tax compliance, you may have back-tax exposure. States are increasingly aggressive about finding out-of-state sellers who should be collecting. Getting compliant now is better than receiving a notice and owing years of uncollected tax plus penalties.
The Merrimack Valley's Trusted Accounting Partner
The Next Step:
A 15-Minute Call
Tell us about your business and what you're dealing with. We'll listen, ask a few questions, and give you a straightforward quote.
More Questions
What are the payroll requirements for employers in Massachusetts?
Massachusetts employers need federal and state tax registration, must withhold state income tax and PFML contributions, register for unemployment insurance, and carry workers' compensation. The Paid Family and Medical Leave program catches many employers off guard.
Read answerWhat is a marketplace facilitator and do I still need to collect sales tax?
A marketplace facilitator is a platform like Amazon or Etsy that processes transactions and collects sales tax on your behalf. You may still need to collect sales tax on direct sales through your own website or other channels.
Read answerShould I start over with new books or fix my existing records?
In most cases, fixing your existing records is the better choice. Starting over sounds appealing but doesn't erase tax obligations or the need for historical documentation. The right answer depends on how far behind you are and what's actually wrong.
Read answerHow do I file sales tax returns for multiple states?
Register separately with each state where you have nexus, track the different filing frequencies and due dates, and either file manually through each state's portal or use software to automate the process.
Read answerHow far back should I fix my bookkeeping records?
Three years is the practical minimum because it matches the standard IRS audit window. Going further back depends on your specific needs like selling the business, getting a loan, or investor due diligence.
Read answerWhat is revenue recognition for software companies?
Revenue recognition determines when you record revenue in your financial statements. For software companies, the key principle is recognizing revenue when you deliver value to the customer, not when payment arrives.
Read answer

